What's Hot?
Netflix Still Commissioning Nigerian Films, Says NFVCB
Why I Respect, Admire Dagri -DJ Neptune
United Nations Harnesses Power Of Music For Peace...
Actor Sues Tyler Perry For $260m, Alleges Sexual...
How Attempt By International Cartel To Steal Benin...
Lead Acting Role Was Uncomfortable But I Loved...
BBNaija Season 9 Reunion Set To Premiere June...
Omoni Oboli Defends Nollywood Films, Says Hollywood Movies...
Singer Flavour Recalls How PSquare Motivated His Music...
Don Jazzy Opens Up on Missed Opportunities With...
  • Home
  • Arts & Exhibitions
  • Culture & Festivals
    • Culture Africana
    • Culture People
  • Fashion & Lifestyle
    • Music, Movies & More
  • News
    • Travel News
  • Opinion
    • Reviews (The Critics)
  • TCN Literati
  • Tourism & Hospitality
The Culture Newspaper
World Culture

Why Is the Dutch Royal Family’s Golden Carriage So Controversial?

by The Culture Newspaper September 16, 2022
by The Culture Newspaper September 16, 2022

An elaborate gilded carriage used by the Dutch royal family may be retired after years of debate over the racist, colonialist imagery that adorns its side panels, reports Titia Ketelaar for local newspaper NRC Handelsblad.

The artwork at the heart of the controversy is an 1898 triptych by Nicolaas van der Waay titled Homage of the Colonies. As Hakim Bishara writes for Hyperallergic, the scene depicts half-naked black and South Asian people “kneeling, prostrating, and offering gifts to a white woman seated on a throne.” Critics argue that these figures—likely enslaved people—are presented as submissive to royal authority.

Known as the Golden Coach, the royal carriage, which has been under restoration since 2015, is slated to go on view at the Amsterdam Museum next June. Per Dutch broadcaster NOS, King Willem-Alexander will make a final decision regarding the carriage’s fate following the exhibition’s conclusion in November.

News of the coach’s potential retirement arrived ahead of Budget Day, an annual event held on the third Tuesday of September to mark the start of the Dutch parliamentary year. Normally, the Golden Coach plays a key role in the celebration, shepherding the Netherlands’ reigning monarch to the Hall of Knights in the Hague, where they deliver a ceremonial speech. (Another royal carriage, the so-called Glass Coach, has filled in for the Golden Coach while the latter undergoes restoration.) But this year’s Budget Day, or Prinsjesdag, will be a muted affair: To help prevent the spread of Covid-19, the Dutch government has canceled the carriage procession and barred spectators.

A close-up view of the 1898 triptych
A close-up view of the 1898 triptych Minister-President Rutte via Wikimedia Commons under CC BY 2.0

Over the past several months, protests against racism and systemic injustice have sparked the removal or recontextualization of controversial monuments and artifacts across the globe. As Hyperallergic notes, an online petition to move the Golden Coach to a museum has received nearly 8,000 signatures to date.

READ More  Archaeologists Make ‘Sensational’ Discovery of Armenia’s Oldest Church

Criticism of the carriage mounted during a series of protests in 2015, reported Timothy W. Ryback for the New Yorker the following year. But public debate over the triptych dates back to as early as 2011, when Suriname-born Barryl Biekman and a number of other Dutch politicians argued in an op-ed that it should be removed from the coach and placed in a museum.

Report an ad

The people of Amsterdam gifted the carriage to Queen Wilhelmina in honor of her coronation in 1898. Per the New Yorker, local craftsmen carved the coach—funded by donations from the “rich and poor alike”—out of teak wood and gilded it with gold.

In June, Prime Minister Mark Rutte acknowledged that the carriage “summons emotions” but noted that “it’s all part of our history,” according to Reuters. The royal family has previously stated that the triptych itself will not be removed from the carriage.

During a press event in July, the king told reporters that he was “following the discussion” raised by Black Lives Matter protests.

Men dressed in royal garb walk alongside an elaborate coach, gilded in gold with large wheels. On the side of the coach, a triptych depicts a white woman on a throne, being offered gifts by half-naked black people, who bow or look downward
The Golden Coach and Homage of the Colonies, as seen in 2008 Julian Parker / Getty Images

“I’m listening to it,” he said, adding, “As long as there is implicit and explicit discrimination in the Netherlands, we must tackle that as a society.”

The Dutch government’s announcement also arrives amid the country’s ongoing reckoning with its colonial history. According to Leiden University’s African Studies Center, Dutch officials enslaved and traded as many as 600,000 African people across the Atlantic Ocean between the 17th and 19th centuries. Due in large part to colonial exploitation and the trade of enslaved people, the Dutch Republic became a wealthy world power.

Last fall, the Amsterdam Museum said it would stop referring to the 17th century as the “Dutch Golden Age.” To reflect this change, the cultural institution undertook measures including updating the name of its “Dutchmen in the Golden Age” exhibition to “Group Portraits of the 17th Century.”

READ More  40 Of The Most Beautiful Places In The US

“The Western Golden Age occupies an important place in Western historiography that is strongly linked to national pride, but positive associations with the term such as prosperity, peace, opulence, and innocence do not cover the charge of historical reality in this period,” said Tom van der Molen, a curator of the 17th century, in a statement. “The term ignores the many negative sides of the 17th century such as poverty, war, forced labor, and human trafficking.”

Source: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/

carriagecontroversialdutchfamilysgoldenisroyalsothewhy
0
FacebookTwitterPinterestLinkedinWhatsappEmail
The Culture Newspaper

previous post
Burna Boy, Tems Bag BET Hip-Hop Awards Nomination
next post
Soludo Advocates ‘Made In Nigeria’ Clothes As Daughter Floats Anambra Fashion Show

You may also like

11 Festivals To Watch Out For This Summer

June 17, 2025

Chris Brown Jokes About ‘Nice’ Jail As He...

June 16, 2025

Skepta Did A Lot For Afrobeats, DJ Obi...

June 15, 2025

Culture Club Reunites At Tribeca Film Festival For...

June 7, 2025

Top Museum Exhibitions During Frieze Week London

June 3, 2025

“Autophagies”: So Much More Than A Culinary Performance

May 23, 2025

Oliver Laxe Returns To Cannes With Mystical Drama...

May 17, 2025

South African Singer Tyla Makes History As First...

May 16, 2025

FG Intervention Will Revolutionize Filmmaking Process, Attract Investors...

May 13, 2025

Why Indiana Jones, Barbie And Other US Films...

May 10, 2025

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment.

Recent Posts

  • Netflix Still Commissioning Nigerian Films, Says NFVCB
  • Why I Respect, Admire Dagri -DJ Neptune
  • United Nations Harnesses Power Of Music For Peace In South Sudan
  • Actor Sues Tyler Perry For $260m, Alleges Sexual Harassment, Assault
  • How Attempt By International Cartel To Steal Benin Artefacts Failed — Oba Ewuare

Sponsored

Recent Posts

  • Netflix Still Commissioning Nigerian Films, Says NFVCB

    June 20, 2025
  • Why I Respect, Admire Dagri -DJ Neptune

    June 20, 2025
  • United Nations Harnesses Power Of Music For Peace In South Sudan

    June 20, 2025

Categories

  • Arts & Exhibitions
  • Culture & Festivals
  • Culture Africana
  • Culture People
  • Fashion & Lifestyle
  • Food
  • Music, Movies & More
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Photo News
  • Reviews (The Critics)
  • TCN Interview
  • TCN Literati
  • Tourism & Hospitality
  • Travel News
  • Travel Trends
  • Travelogue
  • What's Hot?
  • World Culture

Connect with us

Connect with us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • About Us
  • Advertise With Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us

@2025 - The Culture Newspaper. All Right Reserved. Maintained by Freelart

The Culture Newspaper
  • Home
  • Arts & Exhibitions
  • Culture & Festivals
    • Culture Africana
    • Culture People
  • Fashion & Lifestyle
    • Music, Movies & More
  • News
    • Travel News
  • Opinion
    • Reviews (The Critics)
  • TCN Literati
  • Tourism & Hospitality